How is Undue Hardship Met? 

Canadian human rights laws are designed to promote fairness and equality in the workplace. At the same time, they recognize that employers sometimes need to enforce rules that may have a discriminatory impact if those rules are necessary for the job. These rules are called bona fide occupational requirements (BFORs). In simple terms, a BFOR allows an employer to justify a workplace rule if it is reasonably necessary to do the work, even if it negatively affects someone based on a protected ground. 

The case of McNeil v. Telus Employer Solutions (TES) (No. 2), 2024 BCHRT 166 gives helpful guidance on how this works in practice, where an employee’s request for accommodation may be unreasonable or unsupported. 

Background 

In 2018, an employee of Telus Employer Solutions (TES) asked to work from home or from a different location because she believed there were allergens in her office building. TES denied the request because the employee did not provide enough medical evidence to support it. 

The employee then filed a human rights complaint, claiming discrimination based on physical and mental disability. 

TES responded that it had acted appropriately. It said it needed more medical information to understand whether the employee had a disability-related limitation and what accommodation, if any, would be required. 

The Tribunal first dismissed the complaint in 2022, finding that TES could likely rely on a BFOR defence. That decision was later set aside by the British Columbia Supreme Court and sent back for reconsideration. After reviewing the case again, the Tribunal reached the same conclusion: the complaint was dismissed because TES acted reasonably and the employee’s request was not supported by sufficient evidence. 

The BFOR Test 

To rely on a BFOR, an employer must show three things: 

  1. The rule or standard is connected to the job. 
  1. The rule was adopted in good faith. 
  1. The rule is reasonably necessary, meaning the employer cannot accommodate the employee without undue hardship. 

In this case, TES required employees to work in the office, although it allowed some employees to work from home if certain conditions were met. This policy was tied to legitimate business goals like productivity, efficiency, and customer service. The Tribunal found that this satisfied the first part of the test. 

There was also no evidence that TES acted in bad faith, so the second part was met. 

The key issue was the third part, and whether TES had properly considered accommodation. The employee claimed she had a physical disability (related to allergens) and a mental disability (anxiety). However, the Tribunal found that TES did not have enough medical information to confirm any clear work restrictions that required a remote work arrangement. 

Importantly, the Tribunal emphasized that employers are entitled to request medical information to understand an employee’s limitations and what accommodation may be needed. Employers are also judged based on the information available to them at the time, not information that emerges later. 

The Tribunal also found that TES had no reason to know that anxiety was part of the employee’s request, so it could not be faulted for failing to accommodate it. 

In the end, TES had met its duty to accommodate to the point of undue hardship, and the request to work from home was not justified based on the available evidence. 

Key Takeaways for Employers 

This decision reinforces a few practical points: 

  • Accommodation requests must be supported by sufficient medical evidence. 
  • Employers are entitled to ask for details about restrictions and limitations, not just a diagnosis. 
  • The duty to accommodate has limits—employers do not have to accept every request, especially where it would create undue hardship. 
  • Employers will be assessed based on what they knew (or reasonably should have known) at the time. 

In short, while employers must take accommodation requests seriously, this case confirms that they are not required to agree to changes that are unsupported or unreasonable. 

If you have questions about how this decision might apply to your workplace, find yourself dealing with a similar situation, or would simply like guidance on medical leaves and accommodation obligations, the team at SpringLaw would be happy to help. We regularly advise both employers and employees on navigating these issues in a practical and strategic way, feel free to reach out to discuss your specific circumstances. 

Share the Post:

Related Posts

A stack of balanced natural stones against a soft green forest background, representing the balance between employee accommodation needs and employer responsibilities.

How is Undue Hardship Met? 

When an employee requests workplace accommodation, how do you know what’s reasonable and when a request may create undue hardship? In McNeil v. Telus Employer Solutions, the BC Human Rights Tribunal considered the role of medical evidence, bona fide occupational requirements and an employer’s duty to accommodate. Learn what this decision means for Canadian employers making accommodation decisions in practice.

Read More »
Colourful raised hands illustrating AI, workplace inclusion, accessibility and diverse participation.

Can AI Help Build a More Inclusive Workplace? 

Can AI help create a more inclusive workplace? From accessible communication tools to insights about hiring and advancement, AI can help employers spot barriers that are easy to miss. This blog explores how thoughtful AI use can support workplace equity, accessibility, and better decision making while keeping people, accountability, empathy, and responsible leadership at the centre of inclusion efforts.

Read More »
Runners leaving starting blocks on a track, representing how employers can proactively prepare for litigation

Avoid Stress. Proactively Prepare for Litigation

Litigation can arrive faster than you expect, bringing deadlines, paperwork and stress with it. Proactively preparing for litigation can help Ontario employers respond with greater clarity and confidence. From better documentation and clear workflows to compliance reviews and ongoing employment law support, thoughtful preparation can help protect your business, support your team and keep workplace issues from becoming bigger problems.

Read More »

Contact Us

Thank You For Your Interest. Kindly Complete The Form Below. Our Client Services team will be in touch with further information about our fees and intake process.
[grow-contact-form]