Caution to Employers Using Social Media to Vet Potential New Hires

reviewing candidates’ social media
Photo by Austin Distel on Unsplash

This is Part 1 of our two-part series in social media in hiring. Stay tuned for Part 2 next week! 

Today, there are more users on social media than ever before. Scores of people everywhere in the world are posting personal information online. This information is being consumed by billions of people on a daily basis, some for more personal reasons, others less so. Countless employers have, for instance, rapidly shifted to incorporating the extra step of reviewing potential candidates’ social media activity into the hiring processes. Considering the relative novelty of social media technology, employers should brace themselves for increasing litigation around this in relation to employment issues in the years to come. 

Should employers be cautious of reviewing a candidate’s social media accounts during the hiring process?

Employers should tread carefully if they choose to use social media to vet potential new hires. Under the Ontario Human Rights Code, everyone has a right to equal treatment in employment regardless of characteristics such as race, sex, age, disability, sexual orientation, or marital status. Employment includes the hiring process. In reviewing a candidate’s social media accounts, an employer could come to discover some of these personal characteristics, which could contribute to a hiring decision that is both biased and a potential violation of the Human Rights Code.

An employer should have valid, objective and consistent evaluation criteria when selecting potential employees. This can be tricky if employers screen candidates using their social media presence. For example, candidate A may not be on any social media, candidate B could be active on many platforms, all of which have been made publicly accessible, and candidate C could have a social media account on one platform, but with limited publicly available information. Research has found that some social media platforms are more likely to be used by individuals in a particular gender or age group. Including social media, whether formally or informally, as part of the talent acquisition process could lead to inconsistency in candidate profiles. 

Overall, social media rarely paints a comprehensive picture of a potential employee. From a hiring perspective, an employer may run the risk of making a decision disproportionately based on a candidate’s social media accounts, rather than taking in all that the potential employee has to offer. The content of a potential employee’s social media accounts could also easily be taken out of context and misunderstood. 

From a practical point of view, combing through candidates’ social media accounts could be fairly time-consuming, something which may not be feasible for employers with smaller human resources departments or fewer people to fully carry out this process.

A practical way for employers to help lessen the risks around social media in recruitment is to separate the job of reviewing social media posts from the hiring decision-maker, ideally two different people.

Be sure to check the blog next week for Part 2 where we will discuss the risks of hiring bias and social media in more detail.

If you have questions about making appropriate hiring decisions, get in touch for a consultation.

Share the Post:

Related Posts

Colourful raised hands illustrating AI, workplace inclusion, accessibility and diverse participation.

Can AI Help Build a More Inclusive Workplace? 

Can AI help create a more inclusive workplace? From accessible communication tools to insights about hiring and advancement, AI can help employers spot barriers that are easy to miss. This blog explores how thoughtful AI use can support workplace equity, accessibility, and better decision making while keeping people, accountability, empathy, and responsible leadership at the centre of inclusion efforts.

Read More »
Runners leaving starting blocks on a track, representing how employers can proactively prepare for litigation

Avoid Stress. Proactively Prepare for Litigation

Litigation can arrive faster than you expect, bringing deadlines, paperwork and stress with it. Proactively preparing for litigation can help Ontario employers respond with greater clarity and confidence. From better documentation and clear workflows to compliance reviews and ongoing employment law support, thoughtful preparation can help protect your business, support your team and keep workplace issues from becoming bigger problems.

Read More »
Black and white cat showing teeth, illustrating a blog about workplace conflict and just cause for dismissal

Can You Tell Your Boss to F* Off and Keep Your Job? The Ontario Court of Appeal Weighs In 

Can you swear at your boss and still keep your job? Jeff Adams examines an Ontario Court of Appeal decision on just cause, workplace misconduct and condonation. The case shows why context matters when employers respond to threats, insulting workplace communications and misconduct, and why delays in discipline do not always mean an employer has accepted the conduct as permissible.

Read More »

Contact Us

Thank You For Your Interest. Kindly Complete The Form Below. Our Client Services team will be in touch with further information about our fees and intake process.
[grow-contact-form]